The Archbishop of York, Most Rev. Stephen Cottrell, has issued a statement defending his actions in response to a BBC report about his handling of a historical abuse case involving Canon David Tudor. The Archbishop expressed regret over the report, accusing it of “re-traumatising” survivors while maintaining that he acted appropriately within the circumstances.
The controversy stems from a BBC Radio 4 File on Four investigation, which highlighted concerns about Tudor’s ministry. The report revealed that when Archbishop Cottrell became Bishop of Chelmsford in 2010, he was made aware of Tudor’s troubling history, including allegations and convictions of sexual misconduct dating back to the 1980s. Tudor had been suspended and reinstated multiple times, even serving as an area dean overseeing 12 parishes.
In his statement, Archbishop Cottrell described the situation he inherited as “horrible and intolerable,” especially for survivors of abuse. He explained that Tudor was suspended in 2019 when new allegations surfaced, adding that prior to this, there were no legal grounds to take further action.
“I am deeply sorry, but I am extremely disappointed that the story has been presented as if it was an abuser being ignored or protected. Actually, nothing could be further from the truth. And to present it this way only re-traumatises already hurt people,” he said.
Calls for the Archbishop’s resignation have grown, with Rt Rev Dr. Helen-Ann Hartley, Bishop of Newcastle, criticizing his handling of the case. She argued that the Archbishop could have acted sooner and should step down to ensure accountability.
The issue has reignited concerns over safeguarding practices within the Church of England. Archbishop Cottrell reiterated his longstanding support for independent scrutiny of safeguarding efforts, emphasizing the need for transparency and resolution. “I pledge myself to do what I can to achieve this,” he concluded.
READ: Pope Francis Warns Against Divisive Spirituality During Historic Corsica Visit
This development comes amid ongoing scrutiny of the Church of England’s safeguarding practices. The Archbishop of Canterbury, Most Rev. Justin Welby, announced his resignation earlier this year following criticism over the Church’s handling of abuse cases, including the Makin Review into the late barrister John Smyth’s misconduct. Archbishop Welby is set to step down on January 6, with Archbishop Cottrell temporarily assuming his duties until a successor is appointed.
The Church continues to grapple with the impact of these scandals as it seeks to rebuild trust and prioritize the safety of its congregants.
